What color LED street lights are best?

I believe everyone has noticed that some LED streetlights ( cobra head led street lights or modular street lights )on the street emit yellow light, and some emit white light. In our impression, LED street lights in cities generally emit warm yellow light. Street lamps are emitting white light. Why is this so? In fact, the difference between yellow light and white light lies in the choice of the color temperature of LED street lamps, so what color temperature should be used for LED street lamps? Next, LED street lamp manufacturer GRNLED will briefly talk about this issue with you.

LED street lamps emit white light when the color temperature is around 5000K, and yellow or warm white light when the color temperature is around 3000K. In fact, yellow light or warm white light around 3000K is more suitable for road lighting, while the color temperature of LED street lights around 5000K is not suitable for road lighting. Because the color temperature of 5000K will make people feel very cold and dazzling, which will cause people’s vision to be overly fatigued, and under this color temperature condition, people’s ability to observe in the distance will also decrease, reducing the driving safety of drivers. In addition, in rainy and foggy weather, LED street lights with a color temperature of 5000K have poor penetration ability, which also affects the travel safety of pedestrians.

So why are there still many areas using LED street lights with this color temperature?

1. When the early LED street lamps first came out, many LED street lamp manufacturers chose a color temperature of around 5000K, which has led to many manufacturers following suit.

2. Under the conditions of early phosphor technology, LED street lights with cool white light sources have higher luminous efficiency.

3. Today’s LED street lamps lack strict technical standards in terms of product specifications.

The above three reasons have led to the rampant use of 5000K color temperature LED street lights in the market, which is not a good thing for pedestrians. In short, the editor believes that LED street lights with a warm color temperature of 3000K have more advantages, and have more user experience than 5000K color temperature. To improve this situation, LED street lamp manufacturers should recommend warm color temperatures to engineering companies, and engineering companies themselves should change the old thinking of exclusive white light for LED street lamps.

Hello, customers

My name is Ricky Wang, I’m the business manager of GRNLED. I have been in LED lights industry for more than 10 year. Feel free to contact us. I’m happy to provide you the best service and products.

Email:  info@grnled.com | WeChat: ledfixture

Name

Email

*

Whatsapp/Tel Number

*

Company

Message

*

There has been much debate internationally about whether new LED street lights with a colour temperature (CT) of 3000K (Kelvin) provide a more suitable solution than 4000K lights. CT indicates the colour of lights. As a general rule, the higher the CT, the whiter/bluer the light appears.

A number of environmental and astronomical groups say street lighting should be no more than 3000K, since evidence shows lights with a higher CT can disrupt the circadian rhythms of animals and increase skyglow.

On the other hand, research also shows perhaps a 20 per cent benefit in main road safety outcomes for drivers when whiter 4000K lights are deployed as compared to 3000K lights at the speeds and traffic volumes found on main roads. Underpinning this, leading US road safety researcher Dr Ron Gibbons said at an IPWEA conference last year there was a 30-40 per cent increase in the distance at which drivers recognised hazards with higher colour temperature lighting in standardised studies of target detection distance.

Considering these differing viewpoints, what street lighting are state and local authorities in Australia to deploy? IPWEA has developed a strategy that balances all viewpoints.   

Concerns about 4000K LEDs

LEDs have been in the sights of different groups since large-scale deployments began in 2009.

Australia was an early adopter of LED street lighting. In the first big Australian LED deployment, more than 6,000 LEDs were deployed by the City of Sydney beginning in 2012 and these lights demonstrated significant cost and energy efficiency advantages over conventional lights. Others soon followed this example.

In the US, the use of LED street lighting is particularly contentious. In 2016, an American Medical Association (AMA) report recommended that all street lighting be no more than 3000K. The AMA report referenced the harmful environmental effects of LEDs with a CT above 3000K, but also suggested a possible link between these LED lights and damage to the human retina and eyesight.

• vector illustration

The AMA’s recommendation and other similar recommendations have led many cities and council authorities worldwide to adopt their own ‘3000K or below’ approach. But a growing number of organisations such as the US Department of Energy and the Illuminating Engineering Society (IES) believe this approach is unsound.

Why a 3000K or below approach may be flawed in some circumstances

There is now a growing body of evidence suggesting 4000K lights are not harmful to humans. One important Australian study, in particular, casts doubt about the harmfulness of 4000K lighting to humans.

A joint 2019 study by Brisbane City Council, Energex and Queensland University of Technology found blue-light irradiance from LED street lights was just 1/100th of the recommended maximum exposure limit that would constitute a blue-light hazard. In other words, they were not dangerous.

Also in doubt is whether blue light from LEDs constitutes a ‘new threat’ to the environment. For example, in an opinion piece published by the IES, the author makes the valid point that the CFLs, mercury vapour and metal halide used in pre-LED street lighting also contained as high or a higher blue-light content than LEDs.  

Taking into account this evidence and the driver-safety findings, deploying 4000K street lighting may be the best option in certain circumstances – especially if it can prevent injury and save lives on main roads where the greatest risks are.

IPWEA seeking the right balance

The recent IPWEA SLSC Model Public Lighting Strategy aims to balance the different viewpoints, environmental/safety and community concerns. IPWEA recommends 3000K for most residential roads and in parks, which constitutes approximately 70 per cent of all public lighting.

The strategy also recommends 4000K street lighting for main roads. This is based on maximising driver and pedestrian safety. The strategy also recommends using smart controls to dim lighting off-peak and the use of even lower CT lighting to mitigate adverse environmental effects in environmentally sensitive areas.